One of the more challenging aspects of volunteer management is accountability. After all, these individuals are giving us their time, often while balancing work, family, and other commitments. But just because someone is volunteering their time doesn’t mean the organization doesn’t have goals that need to be accomplished. As someone leading a board or committee, how do we hold volunteers accountable without discouraging them from participating?
There are three things to consider:
1. Establish Clear Expectations
It is much easier to hold volunteers accountable when everyone understands what they are supposed to be doing. Do your volunteers have clearly defined responsibilities? Do they understand the committee’s goals and what is expected of them? Are agendas, committee charges, meeting minutes, and other pieces of important information readily available?
Sometimes what appears to be a lack of accountability is really an information problem. Volunteers forget things, get busy with their professional responsibilities, or simply lose track of what they agreed to accomplish. We need to keep information in front of them and make it easy for them to understand what they signed up for.
Making information available is only part of the equation. We also need to make sure volunteers can easily find it and that we are reminding them where it is. Sending a recap after a meeting, including deadlines in follow-up emails, or periodically reviewing committee goals can help keep everyone on track. We shouldn’t assume that because we told someone something once, they will remember it several months later.
We also need to make sure the expectations themselves are still relevant. Committee responsibilities and organizational priorities can change. Taking the time to periodically review those expectations helps ensure everyone is still working toward the same goals.
2. Determine Whether It's a Volunteer Problem or a Position Problem
When a volunteer isn’t performing as expected, our first reaction might be that we have a bad volunteer. But is that really the problem? It could be that we have a mismatch between the volunteer and the assignment. Maybe they don’t have the necessary skills, perhaps they don’t have enough time, or maybe the position simply isn’t something they are interested in doing.
Before determining that the volunteer is the problem, take a closer look at the situation. Have we given them an assignment that matches their skills, interests, and availability? Could they contribute in a different role? Could their responsibilities be adjusted? We need to put volunteers in a position to succeed, and that means recognizing when we may be the ones putting them in a difficult situation.
For example, someone who doesn’t have the time to chair a committee might be perfectly capable of helping with a specific project or completing an individual task. Not every volunteer needs to take on a leadership role, and we shouldn’t overlook the contributions someone can make simply because they aren’t able to commit to something larger.
We also need to look at the volunteer opportunities themselves. If we’re consistently struggling to find people willing to take on a particular responsibility, is it because we’re asking too much? Is the work structured in a way that makes it difficult for someone to participate? Sometimes the solution isn’t finding a different volunteer, but rethinking how we’re asking people to contribute.
3. Address Problems Tactfully and Give Volunteers an Out
There will be times when a volunteer situation just isn’t going to work out. When that happens, it’s important to give the volunteer a way out that allows them to save face. No one wants to admit they couldn’t handle a commitment, even when circumstances outside their control contributed to the situation.
At the same time, we have an organization to run. Sometimes we need to recognize that a responsibility isn’t getting done and find someone else who can take it on. Giving someone an opportunity to step away doesn’t mean we have to leave the position unfilled or allow the work to go unfinished. We need to be able to move on and get the job done while still maintaining a positive relationship with the original volunteer.
The important thing is how we handle that transition. We don’t want someone to feel that stepping away from one commitment means they are no longer welcome to participate. Circumstances change, and someone who can’t fulfill a particular responsibility today might be willing and able to contribute again in the future.
How we handle these situations matters. Other members are watching how volunteers are treated, and a negative experience can discourage others from getting involved. I’ve seen volunteers become unwilling to participate, and even drop their membership, because of how they perceived someone else was treated. Maybe that person wasn’t getting their work done, or perhaps there were other issues involved. Regardless, we need to be as tactful as we can.
This doesn’t mean everyone gets a free pass. Volunteers still need to be accountable, and we need people who will follow through on their commitments. But the volunteer pool is a limited and important resource. We need to be thoughtful about how we manage it.
The Bottom Line
Holding volunteers accountable doesn’t mean treating them like employees or expecting them to put the association ahead of everything else in their lives. It means establishing reasonable expectations, providing the support they need to succeed, and addressing problems when they arise. We need to get the work done, but we also need to remember that these are members who have chosen to give us their time. How we manage those relationships will have a lasting impact on their willingness to stay involved.
Brian Lewis, CAE, CVA
Brian Lewis is an Executive Director with RGI, drawing on his experience in membership development, data management, and strategic planning expertise. He has worked in the association industry since 2009, overseeing a number of unique organizations. Brian is a dedicated volunteer in his community, especially through his ongoing service to the Masonic Fraternity and involvement in the Indiana Society of Association Executives.